Seeking Labels and Rejecting Labels: The Identity Paradox and Platform Mediation in the MBTI and SBTI Youth Subcultures
Main Article Content
Keywords
MBTI, SBTI, youth subculture, platform infrastructure, meme-based resistance, practical paradox
Abstract
The MBTI personality test continues to heat up on the Chinese Internet, resulting in the SBTI meme phenomenon that deconstructs the MBTI classification system. On the one hand, there is the identity construction of “seeking labels”, and on the other hand, there is the deconstruction resistance of “rejecting labels”. The two tendencies appear at the same time in the same cultural field and transform each other. This paradox provides a unique observation perspective for understanding the youth subculture in the digital age. This article sorts out 17 core literatures from 2020 to 2026 and analyzes them along the three clues of “the dynamics of identity construction - memetic resistance - platform mediating mechanism”. The analysis shows that in terms of explaining the motivation of “seeking labels”, some studies have formed a multi-layered consensus from individual psychological compensation to structural dilemma response, but there are still differences on the effectiveness of resistance to “rejecting labels”. Some studies regard it as “ritual resistance”, and other studies judge it as “false resistance”. This article tries to use the “practical paradox” to summarize the transformation logic between “seeking labels” and “rejecting labels”. At the same time, it puts forward that “paradoxical co-optation” is an explanatory concept for understanding the mediating mechanism of the platform, in order to provide a discussable analytical framework for subsequent research.
References
- [1]Williams, J. P., & Wu, S. (2025). The MBTI as a cultural meme, its diffusion on Chinese social media, and its significance for millennials' and Gen-Z's selves and identities. Symbolic Interaction. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1002/symb.70012
- [2]Li, Q., & Fu, Q. (2025). Youth social carnival: The internal logic and risk review of the MBTI craze. Journal of Hubei University of Economics (Humanities and Social Sciences Edition), 22(3), 30–35.
- [3]Sun, J. (2025). From "refusing to be defined" to "seeking definition": The manifestations, causes, and guidance strategies of the contemporary youth MBTI craze. Journal of Southwest University of Science and Technology (Philosophy and Social Sciences), 42(5), 91–98.
- [4]Li, J., & Zhan, M. (2026). Symbolic self-narratives and in-group interaction among contemporary youth based on MBTI. Future Communication. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.13628/j.cnki.zjcmxb.20260121.001
- [5]Wang, P., & Li, B. (2026). The representational patterns and diffusion drivers of SBTI memes. Contemporary Youth Research, (2), 78–86.
- [6]Liu, Y., & Hu, G. (2026). "The cage of labels": The formation mechanism, risks, and governance of the SBTI youth subculture—Observations on youth emotional performance from MBTI testing to SBTI self-mockery. Journal of Youth Studies, (3), 103–111.
- [7]Wang, S. (2024). Behind the popularity of MBTI personality tests: Youth mentality and social structural adjustment. People's Tribune, (6), 78–81.
- [8]Zhou, L., & Pan, Y. (2025). Labelized social interaction under constraint: Alienation and critical reflections on MBTI meme dissemination. Journalism & Communication, (23), 56–58.
- [9]Zhou, C. (2025, August 30). A cultural sociological decoding of the MBTI craze. Chinese Social Sciences Today.
- [10]Chen, A., Zhang, L., & Shu, Y. (2026). Humor, resistance, and reflection: Symbolic interaction and identity construction in youth "X Studies" memes. China Youth Study, (3), 15–23.
- [11]Cao, G. (2026). Algorithms as platform will: The technological construction of users' MBTI-based social identity. Voice & Screen World, (4), 98–100.
- [12]Qin, J., Wang, X., & Zhao, Y. (2023). The communication mechanism of MBTI memes from the perspective of interaction ritual chains: A case study of Xiaohongshu. New Media Research, 9(8), 45–52.
- [13]Chen, F. (2025). MBTI as "reality": A study of knowledge production and dissemination on Xiaohongshu (Master's thesis, Shanghai Normal University).
- [14]Chen, X., & Cao, C. (2024). Identity construction or identity crisis? The popularity of MBTI and youth self-identity. Contemporary Youth Research, (6), 27–39.
- [15]Wang, M. (2020). Beyond the myth of subculture theory: A discussion of online subcultures in the digital age. Cultural Studies, (4), 50–62.
- [16]Wang, X., & Ye, Z. (2024). Platform-driven stylistic changes in meme culture: A case study of "Cat Meme" short videos. China Media Technology, 31(10), 22–26.
- [17]Ma, Z., & Hu, L. (2021). Infinite connectivity: The "breaking-out-of-the-circle" phenomenon of subcultures under the technological logic of online platforms. Journalism and Writing, (6), 21–29.
- [18]Zhang, M., & Zhong, Y. (2021). Self-preservation: Anti-co-optation among contemporary ACG fandoms. Journal of Hubei University (Philosophy and Social Sciences), (5), 69–78.
Article Sidebar
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.