A Review of the Mechanisms Underlying the Impact of Occupational Gender Stereotypes on Male Nursing Students’ Professional Identity

Main Article Content

Suyang Li

Keywords

occupational gender stereotypes, professional identity, nursing, male students, self-efficacy, coping strategies

Abstract

Purpose: This study systematically examines the psychological mechanisms through which occupational gender stereotypes influence male nursing students’ professional identity, providing a theoretical framework for future intervention studies and nursing education practice. Method: Using a literature review approach and drawing on a psychological perspective, this study synthesizes and analyzes domestic research literature on occupational gender stereotypes, professional identity, self-efficacy, attribution styles, coping strategies, social support, and psychological resilience. Result: Gender stereotypes in the nursing profession do not directly determine male nursing students’ professional identity; rather, they exert a negative influence through multiple psychological pathways: they reduce self-efficacy by undermining the processes of success and failure experiences, vicarious experiences, verbal persuasion, and emotional arousal; they induce negative attribution styles that attribute failure to one’s own gender traits; they prompt individuals to adopt negative coping strategies such as self-blame, fantasy, and avoidance; and they lower individuals’ perceived levels of social support. At the same time, positive coping strategies and high psychological resilience can mitigate the negative effects of gender stereotypes to some extent. Conclusion: Occupational gender stereotypes are a complex psychological process. Nursing educators should focus on their underlying psychological mechanisms and enhance male nursing students’ professional identity by boosting their self-efficacy, training them in positive attributions and coping strategies, and strengthening their social support and psychological resilience.

Abstract 0 | PDF Downloads 0

References

  • [1] Li Hangting, Lou Shuhui. (2019). Research progress on professional identity level and promotion strategy of undergraduate male nursing students. China Higher Medical Education, 3–4
  • [2] Ren Qiuyan, Ren Qi. (2020). The Current State of Career Development for Male Nurses in China and Abroad. Traditional Chinese Medicine in Rural Areas, 27, 75-77
  • [3] Wang Yongqiong, Yu Hua. (2019). A Study on Occupational Gender Stereotypes and Professional Identity Among Male Nursing Students. Journal of Nursing in the People's Liberation Army, 36, 69–71.
  • [4] Chen Liying. (2020). An Analysis of the Current State of Professional Identity Among Male Nursing Students in Higher Vocational Education and Its Influencing Factors. Healthcare Vocational Education, 38, 116–118.
  • [5] Zhang Yi, Zhou Hang, Ma Fang, Wang Yanjiao. (2021). A Meta-synthesis of Qualitative Studies on Male Nursing Students’ Experiences in the Nursing Program. Journal of Nursing, 36, 76–80.
  • [6] Dong Lili, Jiao Wenjuan. (2017). A Study on the Correlation Between Self-Efficacy and Professional Values Among Male Clinical Nurses. General Nursing, 15, 3592–3594.
  • [7] Jiao Zishan, Luan Shurong, Wang Qinghua, Lu Han, Guan Qinghai, Tan Hongdong. (2019). A Study on the Relationship Between Self-Efficacy and Interpersonal Communication Skills Among Male Undergraduate Nursing Students. Healthcare Vocational Education, 36, 115–117.
  • [8] Chen Guijie. (2010). A Survey and Analysis of Self-Efficacy Among Male Nursing Students in Vocational Programs and Its Influencing Factors. Qilu Journal of Nursing, 16, 43–45.
  • [9] Kong Linghua, Shen Shiyu, Li Guopeng, Chen Xiaoyun, Li Ping. (2016). A Study on the Correlation Between Professional Commitment, Psychological Resilience, and Attribution Style Among Vocational Nursing Students. Journal of Nursing in the People's Liberation Army, 33, 31–34.
  • [10] Zuo Hongxia, Xiong Xiaomei, Li Yan. (2010). A Study on the Relationship Between Male Nursing Students’ Academic Attribution Styles and Professional Identity. Journal of Nursing, 25, 68–70.
  • [11] Wang Xialu, Liu Huan, Liu Liu, Liu Mengwei. (2016). A Survey on Sources of Stress, Anxiety, Depression, and Coping Strategies Among Male Undergraduate Nursing Students During Their Academic Career. Journal of Qiqihar Medical College, 37, 1226–1229.
  • [12] Tian Yunxia, Zhang Jing, Wang Zhaozhao. (2019). A Study on the Relationship Between Nursing Students’ Coping Strategies and Their Professional Identity and Overall Well-being. Higher Medical Education in China, 11–12.
  • [13] Tang Yun, Jiang Mengke, Zhang Wei, Wang Chuchu. (2020). The Impact of Anxiety and Coping Strategies Among Nursing Students on Professional Identity During the COVID-19 Pandemic. Journal of Baotou Medical College, 36, 90–92.
  • [14] Wang Lurong, Wu Yanping, Zhao Qionglan, Wu Meichong. (2014). A Study on the Correlation Between Social Support Perception and Professional Identity Among Vocational Nursing Students. Nursing Education, 14, 1178–1179.
  • [15] Wang Yixiao, Shi Tieying. (2016). The Current Status and Correlations of Social Support and Professional Identity Among Undergraduate Nursing Students. Modern Clinical Nursing, 15, 51–54.
  • [16] Zhang Xinjian, Li Jing, Zan Haijing, Liu Tao, Zhang Xinyu. (2023). The Relationship Between Psychological Resilience, Academic Engagement, and Professional Identity Among Nursing Students in Higher Education Institutions, 20, 3778–3784.
  • [17] Zhang Shuqi, Shi Ruijie. (2024). A Study on the Correlation Between Professional Identity and Psychological Resilience Among Undergraduate Nursing Students at a Military Academy. Work and Health, 40, 1518–1522.
  • [18] Gao Gai, Ji Xingchen, Jiang Shuqin, Xu Jialing, Wu Xiaowan. (2022). Current Status and Analysis of Psychological Resilience, Adversity Quotient, and Professional Identity Among Master’s Students in Nursing. Work and Health, 38, 1847–1853.